Codification Division Publications: Reports of International Arbitral Awards

Last update: June 3, 2016

Volume X

Table of Contents				PDF
Foreword
Avant-propos
Mixed Claims Commission France-Venezuela
	Protocol, 27 February 1903			3
	Personnel			4
	Opinions :
		Acquatella, Bianchi et al. Case: Paul, Venezuelan Commissioner		5
Mixed Claims Commission France-Venezuela
	Protocol, 19 February 1902			11
	Personnel			12
	Opinions :
		Leduc, St. Ives, Fischer & Co.Case: Paul, Venezuelan Commissioner (for the Commission)
		Rogé Case: Paul, Venezuelan Commissioner (for the Commission)
		Decauville Company Case: Paul, Venezuelan Commissioner (for the Commission)
		Lalanne and Ledour Case: Paul, Venezuelan Commissioner (for the Commission)
		Ballistini Case: Paul, Venezuelan Commissioner (for the Commission)
		Daniel Case Paul: Venezuelan Commissioner (for the Commission)
		Heirs of Jules Brun Case
			Opinion of Venezuelan Commissioner	25
			Opinion of French Commissioner	28
			Additional opinion of Venezuelan Commissioner	32
			Additional opinion of French Commissioner	37
			Opinion of Umpire	38
		Frierdich and Co. Case
			Opinion of Venezuelan Commissioner	46
			Opinion of French Commissioner	46
			Additional opinion of Venezuelan Commissioner	47
			Additional opinion of French Commissioner	49
			Opinion of Umpire	50
		Heirs of Jean Maninat Case
			Opinion of Venezuelan Commissioner	56
			Opinion of French Commissioner	60
			Additional opinion of Venezuelan Commissioner	63
			Additional opinion of French Commissioner	73
			Opinion of Umpire	74
		Antoine Fabiani Case
			Opinion of Venezuelan Commissioner	85
			Opinion of French Commissioner	94
			Additional opinion of Venezuelan Commissioner	97
			Additional opinion of French Commissioner	102
			Opinion of Umpire	107
			Exhibit: Award of Swiss Arbitrator under convention of 1891	139
		Pieri Dominique and Co. Case
			Opinion of Venezuelan Commissioner	140
			Opinion of French Commissioner	146
			Additional opinion of Venezuelan Commissioner	148
			Additional opinion of French Commissioner	150
			Opinion of Umpire	152
		Heirs of Massiani Case
			Opinion of Venezuelan Commissioner	160
			Opinion of French Commissioner	164
			Additional opinion of Venezuelan Commissioner	168
			Additional opinion of French Commissioner	176
			Opinion of Umpire	178
		Company General of the Orinoco Case
			Opinion of Venezuelan Commissioner	187
			Opinion of French Commissioner	217
			Additional opinion of Venezuelan Commissioner	220
			Additional opinion of French Commissioner	243
			Opinion of Umpire	250
		French Company of Venezuelan Railroads Case
			Opinion of Venezuelan Commissioner	288
			Opinion of French Commissioner	317
			Additional opinion of Venezuelan Commissioner	320
			Additional opinion of French Commissioner	333
			Opinion of Umpire	335
Mixed Claims Commission Germany-Venezuela
	Protocol, 13 February 1903			359
	Protocol. 7 May 1903			361
	Personnel			362
	Rules			362
	Opinions :
		Christern, Becker, Fischbach, Friedericy, Kummerow, and Daumen: Duffield, umpire
		Kummerow, Otto Redler and Co., Fulda, Fischbach, and Friedericy Cases
			Goetsch, German Commissioner (Kummerow)	370
			Zuloaga, Venezuelan Commissioner (Kummerow)	372
			Goetsch, German Commissioner (second opinion) (Kummerow)	374
			Zuloaga, Venezuelan Commissioner (second opinion) (Kummerow)	378
			Goetsch, German Commissioner (Otto Redler and Co.)	381
			Zuloaga, Venezuelan Commissioner (Otto Redler and Co.)	383
			Goetsch, German Commissioner (Fulda)	384
			Goetsch, German Commissioner (second opinion) (Fulda)	385
			Zuolaga, Venezuelan Commissioner (Fulda)	386
			Zuolaga, Venezuelan Commissioner (second opinion) (Fulda)	387
			Goetsch. German Commissioner (Fischbach and Friedericy)	388
			Zuloaga, Venezuelan Commissioner (Fischbach and Friedericy)	389
			Duffield, umpire	390
		Valentiner Case
			Duffield, umpire
		Van Dissel and Co., Case
			Goetsch, German Commissioner	405
			Zuloaga. Venezuelan Commissioner	408
			Duffield, umpire	408
		Mohle Case
			Duffield, umpire
		Richter Case
			Duffield, umpire
		Metzger Case
			Duffield, umpire
		Bischoff Case
			Duffield, umpire
		Flothow Case
			Duffield, umpire
		Brewer, Moller and Co., first Case
			Duffield, umpire
		Christern and Co. Case
			Duffield, umpire
		Orinoco asphalt Case
			Duffield, umpire
		Wenzel Case
			Duffield, umpire
		Brewer, Moller and Co., second Case
			Duffield, umpire
		Christern and Co. (liquidators) Case
			Duffield, umpire
		Beckman and Co. Case
			Duffield, umpire
		Faber Case
			Goetsch, German Commissioner	441
			Zuloaga, Venezuelan Commissioner	446
			Goetsch, German Commissioner (second opinion)	451
			Zuloaga, Venezuelan Commissioner (second opinion)	455
			Duffield, umpire	457
		Plantagen Gesellschaft Case
			Duffield, umpire
		The Great Venezuelan Railroad Case
			Duffield, umpire
Mixed Claims Commission Italy-Venezuela
	Protocol, 13 February 1903			479
	Protocol, 7 May 1903			481
	Personnel			482
	Rule			483
	Opinions (questions of procedure) :
		Time for submitting Claims
			Ralston, umpire	484
		Time extended for submitting Claims
			Ralston, umpire	485
		Reception of evidence and Claims
			Agnoli, Italian Commissioner	486
			Ralston, umpire	487
		Burelli Case
			Agnoli, Italian Commissioner	490
			Zuloaga, Venezuelan Commissioner	491
			Ralston, umpire	491
	Opinions (of a general nature) :
		Cervetti Case
			Agnoli, Italian Commissioner	492
			Zuloaga, Venezuelan Commissioner	495
			Ralston, umpire	496
		Postal treaty Case
			Ralston, umpire
		Sambiaggio Case
			Agnoli, Italian Commissioner	500
			Zuloaga, Venezuelan Commissioner	506
			Zuloaga, Venezuelan Commissioner (second opinion)	510
			Ralston, umpire	512
		Mazzei Case		525
			Ralston, umpire	525
		De Zeo Case
			Ralston, umpire
		Boffolo Case
			Zuloaga, Venezuelan Commissioner	528
			Agnoli, Italian Commissioner	529
			Ralston, umpire	531
		Massardo, Carbone and Co. Case
			Agnoli. Italian Commissioner	538
			Zuloaga, Venezuelan Commissioner	540
			Ralston, umpire	540
		Brignone Case
			Agnoli, Italian Commissioner	542
			Ralston, umpire	547
		Gentini Case
			Agnoli, Italian Commissioner	551
			Zuloaga, Venezuelan Commissioner	554
			Agnoli, Italian Commissioner (second opinion)	555
			Ralston, umpire	555
		Guastini Case
			Agnoli, Italian Commissioner	561
			Zuloaga, Venezuelan Commissioner	575
			Ralston, umpire	577
		Revesno et al. Case
			Ralston, umpire
		Guerrieri Case
			Ralston, umpire
		Miliani Case
			Agnoli, Italian Commissioner	584
			Agnoli, Italian Commissioner (second opinion)	586
			Ralston, umpire	588
		Petrocelli Case
			Ralston, umpire
		Tagliaferro Case
			Ralston, umpire
		Giacopini Case
			Ralston, umpire
		Bottardo Case
			Ralston, umpire
		Di Caro Case
			Ralston, umpire
		Cesarino Case
			Ralston, umpire
		Oliva Case
			Agnoli, Italian Commissioner	600
			Zuloaga, Venezuelan Commissioner	604
			Agnoli, Italian Commissioner (in reply)	606
			Ralston, umpire	607
		Corvaia Case
			Agnoli, Italian Commissioner	609
			Zuloaga, Venezuelan Commissioner	621
			Agnoli. Italian Commissioner (second opinion)	625
			Ralston, umpire	628
		De Caro Case
			Agnoli, Italian Commissioner	635
			Zuloaga, Venezuelan Commissioner	640
			Ralston, umpire	641
		Martini Case
			Agnoli, Italian Commissioner	644
			Zuloaga, Venezuelan Commissioner	660
			Ralston, umpire
		Poggioli Case
			Agnoli, Italian Commissioner	670
			Zuloaga, Venezuelan Commissioner	680
			Ralston, umpire	684
Mixed Claims Commission Mexico-Venezuela
	Protocol. 26 February 1903			695
	Personnel			697
	Rules			697
	Opinion :			697
		Del Rio Case		698
			Summary of claim	698
			Gaytân de Ayala. umpire	700
Mixed Claims Commission Netherlands-Venezuela
	Protocol, 28 February 1903			709
	Personnel			711
	Rules			711
	Opinions:
		J. N. Henriquez Case
			Plumley, umpire
		Bembelista Case
			Plumley, umpire
		Salas Case
			Plumley, umpire
		Evertsz Case
			Plumley, umpire
		Baasch and Romer Case
			Plumley, umpire
		J. M. Henriquez Case
			Plumley, umpire
		Arends Case
			Plumley, umpire
		Maal Case
			Plumley, umpire
Mixed Claims Commission Spain-Venezuela
	Protocol. 2 April 1903			737
	Personnel			739
	Opinions :
		Extension of time for submission of claims
			Gutierrez-Otero, umpire	739
		Esteves Case
			Gutiérrez-Otero, umpire
		Padrôn Case
			Gutiérrez-Otero. umpire
		Lozano Case
			Gutiérrez-Otero, umpire
		Mena Case
			Gutiérrez-Otero, umpire
		Franqui Case
			Gutiérrez-Otero. umpire
		Corcuera Case
			Gutiérrez-Otero. umpire 753
		Sanchez Case
			Gutiérrez-Otero. umpire
		Betancourt Case
			Gutiérrez-Otero, umpire
Mixed Claims Commission Sweden and Norway-Venezuela
	Protocol, 10 March 1903			763
	Personnel			765
	Opinions :
		Christina Case
			Gaytân de Ayala, umpire
		Bovallins and Hedlund Cases
			Gaytân de Ayala, umpire
Index
Complete PDF